Skip to main content
Visit our new News website at
Monday, June 18, 2012 - 7:00am

Family Loses Alligator Case

Georgia's highest court says, a Savannah-area golf course and private residential community isn't responsible for an alligator attack.

The decision reverses a lower court ruling but doesn't answer a key question affecting businesses.

Eighty-three year-old Gwyneth Williams was walking near a lagoon in the gated island community called The Landings five-years-ago when an alligator bit her foot and arms off.

She died and her family sued the homeowners association.

The family attorney Mike Connor says, The Landings should've done a better job removing alligators.

"I think what the court was afraid of is creating a situation where communities actually had to go out and look for alligators and do things that would make their communities safe," Connor says. "We believe that's exactly what responsible landowners and land managers should do."

The community's attorneys argued that The Landings wasn't responsible for Williams' death under a legal principle concerning wild animals, "ferae naturae."

But the court's decision didn't address that principle.

The Landings attorney Walter Ballew says, the court's narrow ruling doesn't make a larger statement to Georgia businesses about when they can and cannot be held liable for wild animals that wander onto their property.

"They did not address that issue one way or the other," Ballew says. "So we don't have a precedent on that particular question, which is one we had hoped to establish for future cases."

The case could head back to the court for review.